Indie Madness in May - A Game of Mafia (game thread)

[cheddar]

Do we really want to be doing this?

[Carni]

Fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me.

Vote: Burn

[FTP]

The Burn train is the way to go. That FTP train seems pretty suspicious.

[Ex Mod]

Eh I dunno either you or Burn could've taken out Mb on the first night. FTP are you and Carni mafia together?

[The Burninator]

Although there's nothing I can say to y'alls to convince you not to lynch me since the maff picked up stokem and since last round, I do think you should take me seriously when I say I think, unless JK messed up last night, that doog is a non-town aligned special role, or I was RB'd. One of the two.

[Seba]

Vote: FTP
Reason: Post after KP is suspicious to me. Trying too hard to cover up?

[cheddar]

Although there's nothing I can say to y'alls to convince you not to lynch me since the maff picked up stokem and since last round, I do think you should take me seriously when I say I think, unless JK messed up last night, that doog is a non-town aligned special role, or I was RB'd. One of the two.

How does the KP give you any information on Doog? All it says is that mb was killed by the mafia.

[Seba]

How does the KP give you any information on Doog? All it says is that mb was killed by the mafia.

I'm guessing Burn used his special on Doog? And either it got RB'ed and is not on KP or it didn't go through?

FoS: FTP & cheddar
Reason:
I'm on a hunch and I think you and FTP might be playing for the same team. Probably mafia. FTP voted mb first night and he winds up dead after a NL looks fishy. It looks like you came out in FTP's defense after MK voted for FTP... There's not much else to go on at this point.

[The Burninator]

How does the KP give you any information on Doog? All it says is that mb was killed by the mafia.

I'm not talking about what did or didn't show on the KP.

[cheddar]

I'm guessing Burn used his special on Doog? And either it got RB'ed and is not on KP or it didn't go through?

FoS: FTP & cheddar
Reason:
I'm on a hunch and I think you and FTP might be playing for the same team. Probably mafia. FTP voted mb first night and he winds up dead after a NL looks fishy. It looks like you came out in FTP's defense after MK voted for FTP... There's not much else to go on at this point.

Except MK didn't vote for FTP, so there goes your entire argument.

Also, I've never been a fan of joke bandwagons that lead to actual lynches. We do need to lynch someone, but someone jokingly voting for someone and ending up getting the person lynched is not the best way to go about it.

[Seba]

Except MK didn't vote for FTP, so there goes your entire argument.

Vote: FTP
Reason: Shortest name.

He did. Sure, everyone ended up voting NL. But why vote for MK after he votes for your buddy FTP? Hmmm

[cheddar]

Oh, we're talking night one. I didn't think anyone took those type of votes on n1 seriously.

And my vote was just as joking as his. There was no intent by either of us to actually get someone lynched.

[Seba]

Oh, we're talking night one. I didn't think anyone took those type of votes on n1 seriously.

And my vote was just as joking as his. There was no intent by either of us to actually get someone lynched.

Sounds fair enough. Doesn't mean I get to be suspicious heh

[Ex Mod]

So I'm gonna say we vote FTP then go from there.
Vote FTP

[jason_kroeker]

Cutoff was a little over 2 hours ago. However, busy with family. I should get KP up within the next 2-3 hours though.

Tomorrow's cutoff will remain at the normal time unless these missing 4-5 hours are a problem for any of you. Please let me know if any of you will want KP-3 extended for an additional 24 hours.

[jason_kroeker]

KP-2:

A vote was removed from The Burninator.
FTP was lynched and was the Warlock. He did not meet his win condition.

A Wolf has devoured The Burninator. His role will not be revealed.

Scarecrow was killed by the Mafia and was the Serial Killer. He did not meet his win condition.

Please PM me if I missed anything. I am sending out PM responses for specials now.

[Ex Mod]

So time to start picking on the inactives!

[Seba]

Vote: Doog

[Ex Mod]

I'm more suspicious of Carni or Valynor. Looking at the player list though nobody is really saying anything so yeah.

[Carni]

Vote: Doog

Why?

[Valynor]

I'm more suspicious of Carni or Valynor. Looking at the player list though nobody is really saying anything so yeah.

Weekends are a busy time for me. I should be more active here on in.

[Valynor]

Burn was devoured which is intriguing. Wolf isn't a mafia role, but in order to guess Burns role would be either crazy lucky or basing it off his posts. I'm willing to bet the latter. If that's the case he was probably an investigatory role. Unless I'm mistaken, only mafia can remove a vote. Which sounds like mafia was trying to set him up. The mafia is also killing big name players like Stokem and SC. That actually makes me suspect doog. Most players dont do that.

[jason_kroeker]

Because of the nearly 5 hour delay for posting KP (I had warned at start of game it could be up to 2 hours, but 5 is a bit excessive), I will not be applying Rule 5 for the time from KP-2 cutoff until KP-3. Any specials received between 6pm last night and when I actually posted KP will be considered (I did get a few in that time), unless you change it today.

However, I have heard no objections to the shortened day. So today's cutoff will still be 6pm (with KP being posted hopefully 1-2 hours after that).

[Vinit144]

Vote: Seba

Reason: Have nothing to go on as of now. But Seba seems a bit too excited.

[Seba]

Why?

He's been inactive. First round so dunno if he's usually like this but if he's not on much might as well lynch and see where we go from there. I got nothing on him though.

[Carni]

Burn was devoured which is intriguing. Wolf isn't a mafia role, but in order to guess Burns role would be either crazy lucky or basing it off his posts. I'm willing to bet the latter. If that's the case he was probably an investigatory role. Unless I'm mistaken, only mafia can remove a vote. Which sounds like mafia was trying to set him up. The mafia is also killing big name players like Stokem and SC. That actually makes me suspect doog. Most players dont do that.

There's also the possibility that the wolf got crazy lucky and guessed that burn was mafia. We don't know his role, he might not have been set up he might've been saving himself. Unless of course you know his role wasn't mafia, but how would you know that unless you guessed it mr. Wolf? With it probably 7-3 (town/indie-mafia) or possibly even 8-2 if jk put lots of indies in, I think it's safe to lynch a wolf today.

Vote: Valy

[Valynor]

There's also the possibility that the wolf got crazy lucky and guessed that burn was mafia. We don't know his role, he might not have been set up he might've been saving himself. Unless of course you know his role wasn't mafia, but how would you know that unless you guessed it mr. Wolf? With it probably 7-3 (town/indie-mafia) or possibly even 8-2 if jk put lots of indies in, I think it's safe to lynch a wolf today.

Vote: Valy

I specifically said that that was an option. Its just less likely. You should have read my post better.

[dooglash sontoosh]

Bleh sorry about that. I was on date night all day yesterday and missed KP. I'll keep rereading through the thread to determine who's most deserving of my response

[dooglash sontoosh]

Alright so we have four deaths, two of which actively affect the game, one passively (besides voting/participating), and one unknown.

Now then, things of note (or at least of relevance to me). Burn was devoured after fingering me (to be disucssed later). However, he was also hinting at knowing my role, hence most likely being schitzo/snitch (town cop is done).

Now then, Valynor is targetting me as well. . . need to re-read a bit not sure why he is yet.

[dooglash sontoosh]

Burn was devoured which is intriguing. Wolf isn't a mafia role, but in order to guess Burns role would be either crazy lucky or basing it off his posts. I'm willing to bet the latter. If that's the case he was probably an investigatory role. Unless I'm mistaken, only mafia can remove a vote. Which sounds like mafia was trying to set him up. The mafia is also killing big name players like Stokem and SC. That actually makes me suspect doog. Most players dont do that.

Why kill off big name players? That removes the fun of the game. Everything is more fun when the game has heavy participation (something I've done less of). If I am Mafia/Kill Role (totally possible BTW , no one's asked for my role yet), then I would go after the least active players.

Also, from the best I can tell, Mafia kills whoever sends in the kill last. So either one Mafiaoso is rogue, or they are coordinating their targets (probably the latter).

It'd be interesting to play this round killing off fellow Mafia members when fingering them in open chat, easy way to divert suspicion.

That being said. . .

Vote Valynor

******* won't let me join a game and only has previous prejudices (many of them false, check my playing history).

[dooglash sontoosh]

Votes

Doog - 1
Seba

Seba - 1
Vinit

Valynor - 2
Doog and Carny

Not Voting - 5
Vpin
Mod Gauss (who is this btw?)
cheddar
M-K
Wildfire
Valynor

Jason, may I suggest that we have 48 hour long KP due to low activity in game? That way more people have time to vote/etc.

KP in 2 hours

[Valynor]

Votes

Doog - 1
Seba

Seba - 1
Vinit

Valynor - 2
Doog and Carny

Not Voting - 5
Vpin
Mod Gauss (who is this btw?)
cheddar
M-K
Wildfire
Valynor

Jason, may I suggest that we have 48 hour long KP due to low activity in game? That way more people have time to vote/etc.

KP in 2 hours

Vote: Doog

I said I was starting to suspectyou, I didnt vote for you. I had almost nothing to go off of. That is in no way "targeting" you. Defensive much?

[dooglash sontoosh]

Vote: Doog

I said I was starting to suspectyou, I didnt vote for you. I had almost nothing to go off of. That is in no way "targeting" you. Defensive much?

Suspecting me is targeting .
Not defensive at all, just need someone to lynch, and I chose you! Lucky duck...

[vpindian91]

It's been a busy weekend for me so i haven't been able to follow along with the thread

Vote: Seba

Might as well make it a 3 way tie.

[cheddar]

Vote: Doog
Reason: Admitting that he's choosing to lynch Valy on a whim. I don't trust either of you, but that reasoning is asinine.

[dooglash sontoosh]

Unvote:
Vote: Seba

Don't wanna die. Also Valynor and Cheddar are maf . Confirmed

[Seba]

Unvote:
Vote: Seba

Don't wanna die. Also Valynor and Cheddar are maf . Confirmed

If so, then vote for Valy

[cheddar]

Except I'm not

[Valynor]

Unvote:
Vote: Seba

Don't wanna die. Also Valynor and Cheddar are maf . Confirmed

You are really rusty if you think that.

[Ex Mod]

PM Gotmilk with a picture of a walrus in a tutu for my true identity!
Also
Vote Mouse-Keyboard