Something Wicked This Way Comes - Mafia Gamethread

[The Burninator]

Yup. Town lost, esp. after that lynch.

At least I won't have to read through the piles of trash that will be posted in the thread henceforth

[The Burninator]

I can see why Montana voted for me, and Sapient too, since as far as I know, he still hates my guts.

But why seal the deal on a potentially helpful townie, SC? Why? You know better than this.

Anyway, gl vampires. Pls avenge my death -- kill the meanies who voted for me.

[Valynor]

And you say that with what evidence?

None

[Kerzi]

KP 1

Bubble, bubble, toil and trouble...

Through the streets of town, panic took hold. The town seized one they thought was absolutely responsible for their ongoing misery

The Burninator was lynched, and was The Apothecary

Meanwhile, magic seeped through the streets, falling upon one alone.

Scarecrow was Roleblocked

Amid the chaos, one dark demon grabbed the chance to strike unnoticed.

The Blazin1 was killed and was a Vanilla Townie

[Scarecrow]

But why seal the deal on a potentially helpful townie, SC? Why? You know better than this.

Didn't realise I was the sealing vote. I went the way I did thinking those complaining could be using it as a cover. Would have voted for any of the others doing the same as easily.

[Valynor]

Vote: Scarecrow

Two mafia groups, one kill, SC was roleblocked.

[Scarecrow]

*blinks*
There are a few other options here as well..

Another interesting tidbit is there was only 1 roleblock when there are 3 roleblocking roles. This means either people aren't sending in their roles (my option for the above) or that the other two roleblockers chose the same person.

Both of the mafia each have a roleblock. With the missing roleblocks, is it hard to imagine that the same person didn't send in a kill?

[Sapient]

Vote: MB
Reason: He voted for Burn, so meh.

And Burn was right, this round is really stacked against us. There's 4 mafia, 6 town, and there are no real roles besides role blockers, which makes little sense. The only real role just got killed off, so...

[Sapient]

Vote: Scarecrow

Two mafia groups, one kill, SC was roleblocked.

Actually, you're right.

Unvote: MB

VOTE: SCARECROW

[Eric Rasputin]

A vote and then editing to explain why you're voting for him and now an unvote disregarding his former analysis?

Vote: Sapient

[Rokchick]

Vote: MB
Reason: He voted for Burn, so meh.

And Burn was right, this round is really stacked against us. There's 4 mafia, 6 town, and there are no real roles besides role blockers, which makes little sense. The only real role just got killed off, so...

How do you know that? We haven't been given numbers have we? If you know it then you must be one of them. Having said that, your logic on SC is sound, but so is his. I'm wary of the train riding too soon, but without any other evidence, the stats say SC so far.
Vote: SC
Fos: Sap

[Sapient]

A vote and then editing to explain why you're voting for him and now an unvote disregarding his former analysis?

Vote: Sapient

So editing is bad? And recognizing solid information is also bad? It's more looking like you're trying to find a scapegoat to save your boy.

FOS: Eric

How do you know that? We haven't been given numbers have we? If you know it then you must be one of them. Having said that, your logic on SC is sound, but so is his. I'm wary of the train riding too soon, but without any other evidence, the stats say SC so far.
Vote: SC
Fos: Sap

I was referencing this post:

We have 4 'mafia' I believe.
Vampires and the Werewolves. That means (at least) two kills per KP.

[Sapient]

Amid the chaos, one dark demon grabbed the chance to strike unnoticed.

The Blazin1 was killed and was a Vanilla Townie

Kerzi, shouldn't you also tell us which mafia killed Blazin? Or if both mafia chose the same target? That could explain the one KP.

[Luisss]

Vote: Scarecrow

Two mafia groups, one kill, SC was roleblocked.

Isnt there 3 mafia groups?

Either way, only one kill with SC roleblocked means hes probably in one of them.

Vote: SC

[Scarecrow]

Kerzi, shouldn't you also tell us which mafia killed Blazin? Or if both mafia chose the same target? That could explain the one KP.

That is another scenario I hadn't thought of.
It doesn't fit in with the other missing roles however.


By the OP, there are 4 mafia split into 2 teams. The remainder are town with a mason group.

[Rokchick]

Let's hope the masons are on point then!

[Sapient]

Let's hope the masons are on point then!

Do they masons even have a power besides role blocking?

[Eric Rasputin]

So editing is bad? And recognizing solid information is also bad? It's more looking like you're trying to find a scapegoat to save your boy.

FOS: Eric



I was referencing this post:

Deadpool's post was posted on 09:51 AM EST and KP was posted at 09:36 PM EST. Valy's post about the alleged incrimination of SC was 09:47 PM and your post about voting for MB was posted at 10:01 PM.
You had more than enough time to select who you were going to vote for. Yet, you edited your post twice and then unvote because you suddenly agree with Valy and Deadpool? And you think I'm the scummy one here? Yes I was about to vote for SC as Valy's analysis is sound, but when you unvoted I changed my mind, you sound equally scummy as SC and I voted for you.

[Sapient]

Deadpool's post was posted on 09:51 AM EST and KP was posted at 09:36 PM EST. Valy's post about the alleged incrimination of SC was 09:47 PM and your post about voting for MB was posted at 10:01 PM.
You had more than enough time to select who you were going to vote for. Yet, you edited your post twice and then unvote because you suddenly agree with Valy and Deadpool? And you think I'm the scummy one here? Yes I was about to vote for SC as Valy's analysis is sound, but when you unvoted I changed my mind, you sound equally scummy as SC and I voted for you.

I know see why editing is bad, since it gives the mafia straws to grasp onto.

Deadpool, or Cis, can you post my edits for everyone to see? There were small corrections, like putting around the FOS or Vote:

And you can claim you were going to vote for SC all you want after trying to throw me under the bus, but you were quiet until you found a scape goat.

[Eric Rasputin]

I know see why editing is bad, since it gives the mafia straws to grasp onto.

Deadpool, or Cis, can you post my edits for everyone to see? There were small corrections, like putting around the FOS or Vote:

And you can claim you were going to vote for SC all you want after trying to throw me under the bus, but you were quiet until you found a scape goat.

It also gives the town straws to grasp on.

I am trying to throw you under MY bus, not everyone's. I voted for you and I dont expect the others to follow me. You feel like scum to me so I voted for you, I don't care if the others feel different.Plus, I am not trying to prove you're scum to everyone else, just to you.

[Sapient]

Lol. Well, Cis will clear this up.

I'm off to bed. I don't wish to wake up with a guillotine around my neck, so don't make any drastic decisions guys.

We also need word back from OP about if both kills targeted Blazin before I'll be fully committed voting for SC.

[Valynor]

So Sap, I know you don't know this, but double posting is allowed here because editing looks scummy. Eric, Sap isn't a regular to mafia. Cut him a bit of slack.

[Eric Rasputin]

So Sap, I know you don't know this, but double posting is allowed here because editing looks scummy. Eric, Sap isn't a regular to mafia. Cut him a bit of slack.

Understood. Even if I overlook the editing,I still think he's scum based on his unvote and his voting reasons.

[Scarecrow]

So, it is obvious which faction Sap is not.

[Mod Deadpool]

Vote: Scarecrow.

Best option at the moment.

Eric, I don't like what you are doing. Anyone posts anything and you jump on them screaming mafia. That doesn't help us, it just confuses us. Please try not to do that.

[Sapient]

So, it is obvious which faction Sap is not.

Which is that?

[mbstokem]

Vote: Scarecrow

[Flossie Schmumpus]

Sorry I missed most of yesterday. I will be back reading carefully and vote when I am done. From my quick perusal it seems to me Scarecrow is a good bet as mafia...I want to read the hints and clues for the other mafia....because there are three more we need to find.

[Eric Rasputin]

Vote: Scarecrow.

Best option at the moment.

Eric, I don't like what you are doing. Anyone posts anything and you jump on them screaming mafia. That doesn't help us, it just confuses us. Please try not to do that.

Ummm... I did not scream Mafia. Like everyone, I voted, stated my reason and justified it in my view. Like I said in my earlier post, I voted for Sap and I don't expect anyone to follow me. I don't remember creating a post marathon about how Sap is conf Mafia. Please do understand my intentions before you judge me. I know SC is Mafia and there is enough evidence to prove that. Instead of just adding another vote to the bandwagon that is clearly going to win, I want everyone to look at Sap skeptically for the next kp.

[Sapient]

Ummm... I did not scream Mafia. Like everyone, I voted, stated my reason and justified it in my view. Like I said in my earlier post, I voted for Sap and I don't expect anyone to follow me. I don't remember creating a post marathon about how Sap is conf Mafia. Please do understand my intentions before you judge me. I know SC is Mafia and there is enough evidence to prove that. Instead of just adding another vote to the bandwagon that is clearly going to win, I want everyone to look at Sap skeptically for the next kp.

I see it more as if scare is mafia, you look like you're protecting him.

[Scarecrow]

So, when I die, Sapient is VT and Flower is witch.

[Eric Rasputin]

I see it more as if scare is mafia, you look like you're protecting him.

Read my post properly

I know SC is Mafia and there is enough evidence to prove that. Instead of just adding another vote to the bandwagon that is clearly going to win.

I am protecting him?

[Eric Rasputin]

I'm telling everyone before hand that I might not be able to post in the next few days because a storm has hit my city and it's chaos over here. There was a huge blackout and it might happen again. In case I don't post here or reply on skype by the next kp(the one after this) please do find a replacement for me.

[Sapient]

So, when I die, Sapient is VT and Flower is witch.

What is VT? And how do you know flower is the witch?

[Scarecrow]

VT = Vanilla Town
Flower being witch fits in with my previous musings.

[Valynor]

VT = Vanilla Town
Flower being witch fits in with my previous musings.

Who is Flower?

[Scarecrow]

Blargh.

Flower = Flossie

[Sapient]

Read my post properly



I am protecting him?

I feel like after I changed my vote to Scarecrow, you wanted to divert attention from him by bringing it on to me. When that failed and the attention did get placed on to Scarecrow, you then backpedaled and admitted he does look guilty, but so does Sapient.

Which makes me feel that if Scarecrow happens to be mafia, then so are you.

I'm confused as to Scarecrow's intentions when positing that I'm vanilla town and Flossie's the witch (besides RL ). If he's mafia, it would make us look guilty by him giving us a clear "musing." Which could help his hand. Or he could be warning the other mafia team to kill Flossie if he really believes she's the witch? Not really sure.

Though, Flossie is very quiet this round.

[Sapient]

So, Promter, Luisss, and Flossie are being really quiet.

You think Promter and Luisss are the other team?

[Valynor]

I feel like after I changed my vote to Scarecrow, you wanted to divert attention from him by bringing it on to me. When that failed and the attention did get placed on to Scarecrow, you then backpedaled and admitted he does look guilty, but so does Sapient.

Which makes me feel that if Scarecrow happens to be mafia, then so are you.

I'm confused as to Scarecrow's intentions when positing that I'm vanilla town and Flossie's the witch (besides RL ). If he's mafia, it would make us look guilty by him giving us a clear "musing." Which could help his hand. Or he could be warning the other mafia team to kill Flossie if he really believes she's the witch? Not really sure.

Though, Flossie is very quiet this round.

Your instincts are good. I as well was confused as to the purpose of that reveal if he's not mafia.